British columnist Petronella Wyatt argues that by prioritizing careers and financial independence, women have been led to neglect aspects of life such as marriage and motherhood. Drawing on her own life experiences, she contends that certain conventional feminist ideas have steered women of her generation down the wrong path—a claim that has sparked considerable debate.
The feminist movement has long advocated for women’s rights, autonomy, and equal opportunity in the workplace. However, British writer and columnist Petronella Wyatt believes that some of the movement’s core tenets have failed to deliver the desired outcomes in women’s personal and family lives.
Now in her fifties, Wyatt reflects on her own life, asserting that feminism has let down her generation. In her words, “Feminism has let me down—it has let down my entire generation.”
In an article published in the British newspaper *The Daily Mail*, titled “Feminism Has Left Middle-Aged Women Like Me Single, Childless and Depressed,” Wyatt shares not only her own story but also the experiences of several female friends of a similar age.
She describes how she meets with a group of female friends every Monday at a London restaurant. All of them are in their fifties, highly educated, and professionally successful. Yet, they share a common reality in their personal lives: none of them are married, and none have children.
According to Wyatt, despite their professional achievements and academic credentials, many of them grapple with a profound sense of emptiness. At this stage in their lives, they have come to realize that while professional success is significant, building personal relationships and a family is equally important.
Learning to View Marriage as Something Shameful
Reflecting on her childhood and upbringing, Wyatt writes that she was introduced to feminist ideology from a young age; one of her aunts was actively involved in the women’s rights movement. At the age of just 13, she received books by feminist thinkers Gloria Steinem and Simone de Beauvoir as a gift.
She argues that the feminist ideology of that era encouraged women to emulate male behavior and to devalue marriage and traditional family life.
The author claims that this influence extended into her school years; expressing an interest in marriage was often viewed negatively. Citing the experience of a friend, Watt recounts how a teacher mocked her for looking at a magazine featuring wedding attire—the teacher believed that educated women should focus on intellectual pursuits rather than marriage or domestic life.
According to Watt, many women of her generation were conditioned to view domestic life and motherhood as obstacles to their personal freedom and professional success.
The impact of a negative attitude toward men
Watt shares the experience of a friend who, under the influence of feminist teachings, came to perceive traditional femininity as a restrictive construct imposed by men. This fostered a negative attitude toward men, leading her to keep her distance in personal relationships.
Quoting her friend, Watt notes that feminism had taught her to believe that engaging in a relationship with a man—or embracing traditional femininity—was tantamount to sacrificing one’s own freedom. Looking back from her current stage in life, her friend now regrets having held that perspective.
In Watt’s view, love, companionship, and mutual support are of profound importance in human life. Neither professional success nor financial independence can dispel loneliness. Many women, particularly in middle age, come to realize that their lives lack meaningful emotional connections and family.
She further observes that some women she knows did not achieve the professional success they had anticipated, and many have found it difficult to sustain themselves on a single income. Consequently, the ideal of financial independence—once championed as the ultimate life achievement—has, in reality, failed to guarantee a comfortable life for everyone. Career or Family—Why Not Both?
The core argument in Watt’s writing is that a career and a family should not be presented as competing choices for women. A woman can be highly educated and professionally established, while simultaneously building a fulfilling family life with a spouse and children.
In her view, women’s freedom should never be interpreted as rendering men or family life unnecessary. Rather, true freedom lies in having the opportunity to shape one’s life according to one’s own personal choices.
Watt mentions that a 20-year-old student recently stayed at her home for a while. Through conversations with this young woman, she realized that some women of the new generation no longer view marriage and motherhood in the same negative light as before. While this student believes in women’s rights, she does not align with the rigid or anti-male feminist perspectives held by previous generations.
According to Watt, the push for women’s rights was historically necessary. In the past, women were often dependent on their fathers or husbands, and their opportunities to lead a life of their own choosing were limited. Today, however, women enjoy far greater opportunities and freedom. Consequently, it is time to re-examine certain long-standing concepts within feminist thought.
Statistics also reflect shifts regarding childlessness.
Official statistics from the United Kingdom also reveal shifts in childbearing trends among different generations of women. A 2016 report by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) indicated that approximately 17% of women born in 1970 were childless—a figure that stood at 12% for the preceding generation, those born in 1943.
Another ONS report, published in 2019, showed that nearly 49% of women born in 1989 had not given birth by the age of 30; for their mothers’ generation, this figure was 38%.
However, these statistics do not imply that feminism is the sole cause of childlessness or the decision not to marry. The ONS notes that a variety of factors are involved, including education, career, financial circumstances, marriage trends, the costs of raising children, and personal preferences.
**Counterarguments to Watt’s claims**
Following the publication of Petronella Watt’s remarks, a counter-discussion emerged in the British media. In an article for the *Daily Mail*, author Mandy Appleyard criticized Watt’s position.
Drawing on her own experience of living an unmarried and childless life, Appleyard argued that it is unreasonable to blame feminism for the disappointments one may feel in their own life. She asserts that the core objective of feminism is to ensure equal rights and opportunities for both men and women—a movement that has opened doors for women today that were not accessible to previous generations.
Consequently, the debate is no longer confined to whether feminism is “good” or “bad.” Instead, the central focus has shifted toward how women can strike a balance between personal freedom, professional success, marriage, motherhood, and individual fulfillment.
Petronella Watt’s comments essentially reflect the unfulfilled aspirations and regrets felt by some women of her own generation. While not everyone may share her perspective, her remarks have brought a significant question back to the forefront: should the pursuit of women’s rights be balanced with an equal emphasis on the desire for family, love, and a fulfilling personal life?
Source: Yahoo News and the *Daily Mail*












